The
Control Model –
When to take corrective actions?
One of the challenges in establishing an effective project control system
is to know when to make corrective actions. The ultimate corrective action
is changing the baseline. Measurement and Evaluation without Action is
useless, but Action without adequate Measurement and Evaluation is just
as damaging. W. Edwards Deming has given us some guidelines based on
statistics.
In his “Funnel Experiment,” he
asks you to imagine balls dropping through a funnel toward
a target on the floor. The balls represent weekly progress,
and the target simulates the baseline budget created during
planning. Do the balls always land on the bulls eye? No - perfection
is unrealistic for most projects. Deming says that over a statistically
significant period of time, the smallest variance from
the plan (see red circle) results from monitoring against a
consistent
baseline. If corrective action is taken before you have statistical
results, divergence may result. You should work with the team
daily to meet milestones, but wait to change the baseline.
Item-by-item compensation can destroy a system
that is already “in
control.” |